Six Common Pitfalls When Reading Scripture With Children
Dr. Robin Turner
This past spring, All Saints Dallas hosted a weekly women’s Bible study titled, “Learning to Love the Old Testament,” a combination of Old Testament survey, biblical literacy, a crash course in geography, genre and historical timelines, and personal application. As we studied, I noticed that our conversations and questions often included unlearning perceptions of Old Testament stories formed through childhood and adolescent Scripture reading and Sunday school classes.
As the semester closed, I had the opportunity to teach a “bonus class” for those interested in applying our learning toward thoughtfully reading Scripture with children. I shaped the class around “Six Common Pitfalls When Reading Scripture With Children,” which helped women identify ways that their reading of Scripture had sometimes been misguided, and offered a more faithful approach to reading Scripture. In reality, these six common pitfalls are helpful to recognize at any age, both in personal devotional and community study contexts!
- Personalizing the Story: The Bible is one of God’s most amazing gifts to us, but we are not its original contextualized audience. When we read our personal cultural values, personal emotions and familial contexts into stories, we often miss the point of the story. By claiming a promise God makes to a specific person or group of people, we can misunderstand both how God was at work in the context of the biblical narrative and what he might be doing in our lives today.
- Behaviorism: The Bible was not written primarily for our personal character development or to optimize children’s Sunday school applications. The Bible is about revealing God’s character through God’s story and inviting us into relationship with God. For example, the application of Noah is not learning to wait with patience through trials, Esther is not about seeking courage in hard times, David and Goliath is not about overcoming personal obstacles through prayer and Jesus feeding the multitudes is not about a little boy’s sacrificial gift. Rather than first jumping to “how can I apply this story?” we can first ask “Who does God reveal himself to be in character or action in this story?” and then “How can I trust and walk with God more faithfully today based on knowing his character and power more fully from this Scripture?”.
- Bible Heroes: While there are many qualities to emulate from the men and women of faith in the Bible, and we might find inspiration from their stories, stories that focus on the life and character of an individual are not meant for us to wholeheartedly adopt with our actions. For example, Daniel showed great steadfastness in worshiping the Lord (Daniel 1), but that does not mean that we need to adopt his dietary choices as our personal act of obedience. David worshiped the Lord wholeheartedly and without shame (2 Samuel 6), and we can fully worship while fully clothed.
- Karma as Explanation: Karma is a Hindu and Buddhist concept that the spiritual world is full of cause-effect consequences where positive choices lead to positive outcomes because of an impersonal and cosmic force. Christians believe in a relational God who loves us fully and blesses, disciplines, judges and calls to repentance. When the Bible talks about blessings and curses, these are coming from a relational God who is full of wisdom, grace, love and mercy, not a distant cosmic force. Christians can actually expect that they will face times of difficulty and trial, not that their obedience to God will result in constant positive experiences.
- De-Intensifying Themes: Some content of Scripture is too weighty or mature for children and contains themes that are sexually explicit, intensely violent or highly destructive. In an effort to share the whole of Scripture with children, there’s a temptation to censor stories to the point of revising history. In these cases, it’s appropriate to wait to share a story from the Bible until it can be taught truthfully. For example, when I discuss the 10 Commandments with children, I explain that adultery is “acting married with someone you’re not married to.” When teaching the story of Joseph, we can faithfully say, “Potiphar’s wife lied about Joseph, and he was sent to jail.” We don’t need to teach stories focused on rape, incest or genocide to young children.
- Finding Jesus Everywhere: There are many ways that the Old Testament prophesies the coming of the Messiah and the need of a Savior, but not every small story needs to be read with a goal of finding a connection to Jesus. The narratives of Scripture are true stories that reveal the person and character of God and God’s work, and sometimes those stories reveal other truths about God without prophesying about Jesus.
The goal in providing a list of common misreadings of Scripture is to better equip Christians of all ages to study the Bible, encounter the work and character of God, and live faithfully, not discourage Scripture reading for fear of accidentally misreading or misapplying the passages. One of the joys of the Christian life is finding that the truths of Scripture can be better understood and applied throughout a lifetime of biblical study, and reading Scripture with children is hopefully only a starting point for a lifelong love of encountering the love of God and the goodness of our Savior in the living text of God’s Word.
Dr. Robin Turner serves as catechist of All Saints Dallas. She lives in the Oak Cliff neighborhood with her husband, Sam, the headmaster at an urban classical school, and their three young children. She is the editor of "Children’s Ministry and the Spiritual Child" (ACUPress, 2022), founder of www.worshipwithchildren.com and vice-chair of the Children’s Spirituality Summit. Robin completed her BA and MA in Christian Formation and Ministry at Wheaton College, and her DMin in Leadership and Spiritual Formation at Portland Seminary. Her writing and research focuses on children’s spiritual formation, intergenerational worship and sustainable ministry practices.
Category: Children
Tags: Bible Study, Children's ministry, Scripture, children