Serving in the Thoughtful Process of Discernment
Calli Birch

Michael McGee during his ordination
When Dustin+ Messer reached out to me in May of 2025 to ask if I’d be willing to serve on the discernment committee for Michael McGee, I responded first with questions. What is the process? When would we meet? And did I really “qualify,” considering my relatively recent confirmation into the Anglican church? I don’t remember if I actually spoke that last question aloud or if it simply lingered in my head, but I do remember how honored I felt to be selected. AMiA guidelines explain that the “local discernment team should comprise at least three to five people … who are not related to the aspirant, have a history of discernment and the ability to speak the truth in love. The team’s goal is to assist the applicant in prayerfully and thoughtfully discerning whether the applicant’s call is to ordained ministry.”
What a meaningful mission! Having come from a nondenominational background, I admired the intentionality of purpose and the slow thoughtfulness with which Anglicanism approaches important decisions. Discernment should not be rushed.
Throughout the summer, our committee met a total of seven times in various arrangements, often with Michael, sometimes just among ourselves and once with Mallory McGee, Michael’s wife. We met in the church office, and we also met on Zoom. Dedicating ourselves to regular prayer, we asked the Lord for direction and Spirit-led discernment.
One thing that particularly impressed me was the atmosphere and tone of each meeting. We were partnering with the church and Michael in seeking God’s guidance for his future ministry, and Michael humbly, even joyfully, trusted the process.
During our first meeting, we listened to Michael’s story, hearing his testimony and learning about his previous ministry experiences. In subsequent meetings, we focused on his preaching, his biblical knowledge, his ministerial vision, his spiritual habits and ultimately his alignment with Anglicanism and the AMiA. We listened to his sermons and reflected on his leadership of All Saints Youth, where he spiritually leads my two teenage daughters.
With each meeting, we asked the Holy Spirit to guide us and be present in our conversations. I noticed how every individual committee member brought unique value to our group, asking different kinds of questions, perceiving things others had missed. It never felt like an interrogation or even an interview; it was a thoughtful process I now wish every minister and missionary could experience. What a gift to be granted the time and space to purposefully reflect on your story with the Lord and your calling into his ministry. What a blessing to seek wisdom in community!
Being on Michael’s discernment committee ultimately led me to a greater appreciation for our Anglican tradition and a deeper understanding of the heart behind ordination. While I already admired and trusted the leadership of our clergy, it led me to value the weight of their calling. I’m left incredibly grateful to be shepherded by those who have humbly submitted themselves to the Good Shepherd.
Calli Birch is an English literature and writing educator in Keller, Texas. She guides students through the great books at storyweaverco.com and is blessed to worship at All Saints Dallas.
Category: Anglicanism, Leadership
Tags: discernment, ordination